Skip to content
MoveUpPhilly

By Craig Lerch · Relocation Guide

2026-11-04 · 8 min read

Do I Pay More in Taxes in Philadelphia Than Florida?

Craig Lerch

Craig Lerch

Broker · EXP Realty · License AB060964L

Cover photo for the guide: Do I Pay More in Taxes in Philadelphia Than Florida?

Not automatically. Florida charges no income tax, but Pennsylvania adds a flat 3.07% on wages and Philadelphia adds a city wage tax of 3.735% for residents and 3.425% for non-residents who work in the city. Property taxes are roughly comparable, and Florida homeowners insurance averages four to five times Pennsylvania's. The number depends on address, job, and what you buy.

I'm Craig Lerch, a broker at eXp Realty, and this is the first question out of almost every Florida conversation I have: Florida advertises a 0% income tax, Philadelphia's tax list is longer, so does the move raise my tax bill? The honest answer, with every rate verified in November 2026 from the Florida Department of Revenue, the Pennsylvania Department of Revenue, the Tax Foundation, and the City of Philadelphia, is that the two states collect very differently, and the total follows the address.

The income-tax headline: 0% against a flat 3.07 plus a wage tax

Florida has no state personal income tax at all; its constitution bars one. Pennsylvania taxes earned income at a flat 3.07% with no brackets, and the City of Philadelphia adds its wage tax on top: 3.735% for city residents and 3.425% for non-residents who work in the city, the rates in effect since July 1, 2026 (PA Department of Revenue; phila.gov, verified November 2026). Add the two and a wages-earning Philadelphia resident pays 6.805% of earned income in combined state and city income tax before federal withholding; a non-resident who commutes into the city pays 6.495%. That earned-income line is where Florida wins on paper, and it is why most people who move here from a no-income-tax state feel a smaller paycheck at first.

Two caveats keep the headline honest. The wage tax follows the work address more than the home: live in the Pennsylvania suburbs and work in the city, and the 3.425% non-resident rate applies; live and work entirely outside Philadelphia, and the wage tax does not touch you, though the flat 3.07% state rate still applies everywhere in Pennsylvania and most suburbs add their own earned income tax of about 1%, capped at 2% under Act 32 (phila.gov; PA DCED, verified November 2026). If you work remotely from Pennsylvania for an out-of-state employer, the state still taxes wages for work performed here, and the telework rule for non-residents gets its own treatment in this site's wage-tax guide.

Property tax: the low average hides the reset

Florida's average effective property tax rate looks low, about 0.67% to 0.76% of home value in 2026 estimates (MoverDB; Schwab, verified November 2026). Pennsylvania's statewide average is around 1.3% (Tax Foundation; MoverDB, verified November 2026). Philadelphia County sits between them at about 0.83% median effective (SmartAsset, verified September 2026). The property line is not the surprise; the mechanism is.

Florida's low average is partly a mirage for newcomers. The Save Our Homes rule caps annual assessment growth on a homesteaded property at 3% (2.7% for 2026), on top of a homestead exemption of $25,000 plus a second indexed piece. But the cap does not transfer when a home sells: your assessment resets to full market value the year after you buy, and the cap only starts protecting you in year two (Florida Department of Revenue, verified November 2026). A new Florida owner can pay property tax on today's price a few doors down from a neighbor paying on a 2005 assessment. Philadelphia runs the opposite shape: the Homestead Exemption takes $100,000 of assessed value off an owner-occupied bill for those who apply, worth up to about $1,399 a year (City of Philadelphia, verified September 2026).

Sales tax: the same 6% base, then a split

Both states set the base state rate at 6%. Florida's counties add discretionary surtaxes that lift the average combined rate to about 6.98% (Tax Foundation, midyear 2026 data). Pennsylvania allows just two local add-ons, Philadelphia's 2% and Allegheny County's 1%, so most of the state is 6% and the City of Philadelphia is 8% (Tax Foundation; phila.gov, verified November 2026).

The basket matters as much as the rate. Pennsylvania exempts most clothing and shoes from its 6%; Florida taxes ordinary clothing at the full rate with narrow carve-outs for baby clothes and an annual back-to-school holiday. Both states largely exempt groceries bought for home use, though Florida's list is narrower: fresh produce, meat, dairy, and bread are exempt, while candy, soft drinks, and hot prepared food are taxable (state sales tax guides, verified November 2026).

Homeowners insurance: the line that flips the total

Florida has the most expensive homeowners insurance market in the country. Published 2026 averages run about $5,700 to $8,300 a year depending on coverage amount and source, against Pennsylvania's average of about $1,300 to $1,700 (Hartford; Pearlscore; Insurify; NerdWallet, verified November 2026), a four- to five-times gap. On a $400,000 house the difference can be $4,000 to $6,000 a year, enough to outweigh the income-tax line for many households. Wind exposure, flood zone, and roof age drive the Florida quote, so the only number that counts is a quote at the exact property address, available before you make an offer.

How the answer splits across the metro

Run the same comparison at three addresses and the answer splits.

  • City of Philadelphia, live and work inside it: 3.07% state plus the 3.735% resident wage tax, an 8% sales tax, and a roughly 0.83% effective property rate with the $100,000 Homestead Exemption available to owner-occupants.
  • Pennsylvania suburb, commute into the city: 3.07% plus the 3.425% non-resident wage tax, an effective property rate around 1.3% to 1.84% depending on county, and a suburban earned income tax typically near 1%.
  • Fully outside the city, working outside it too: the wage tax disappears, and the state 3.07% plus the local earned income tax remains.
  • New Jersey and Delaware: New Jersey residents who work in Philadelphia credit the wage tax against New Jersey income tax; Delaware residents generally get no such credit, a rule the U.S. Supreme Court left standing when it declined the case in January 2024 (verified September 2026).

What genuinely surprises people from Florida

Three things come up in almost every Florida conversation. First, that Philadelphia has its own income tax at all; it is one of only a handful of major U.S. cities, New York among them, with a true wage tax, and no Florida city has anything like it. Second, that the city-versus-suburb choice is a tax choice: a fully suburban household avoids the wage tax entirely while a city household pays it on every dollar of earned income, a swing of thousands a year at a working salary. Third, that Pennsylvania's sales tax skips clothing and most groceries while Florida's does not, so the lower-sales-tax state depends on what a household buys.

And the detail no national listicle carries: Florida's cheap property-tax average is built on assessment caps that reset to full market value the year after you buy, so a brand-new Florida owner often pays more property tax than the state average suggests.

What most people get wrong

  • That Florida is tax-free. It has no income tax, and it collects instead through property assessments that reset on resale, sales tax on clothing, and the country's highest homeowners insurance premiums, all of which hit a new buyer immediately.
  • That the wage tax is a one-time fee. It is a payroll withholding on earned income, like federal tax, charged every pay period to city residents and to non-residents who work in the city.
  • That moving to the suburbs dodges Pennsylvania tax. The flat 3.07% state rate follows you anywhere in Pennsylvania; suburbs add their own earned income tax, and only the city wage tax specifically disappears.
  • That Philadelphia's higher 8% sales rate is quietly offset elsewhere. The 8% is higher than Florida's roughly 7% average combined rate, and the genuine offsets are narrower than people think: clothing and most groceries are exempt in Pennsylvania.
  • That a state average tells you your number. Every line moves with an address: the county millage, the insurance quote, and the commute pattern that decides whether the wage tax applies.

Your concrete next step

Build the comparison on four lines for one specific address: earned-income tax (state plus city or suburb, keyed to your work location), effective property tax at the actual purchase price, sales tax on your typical spending mix, and a homeowners insurance quote. The sources above publish all four, and the county assessor plus one insurance quote finish the sheet.

I will put your actual salary, work ZIP, and target house price into a personal tax sheet, so the number is yours, not a state average. Book a free 20-minute consultation call, no follow-up, to get that sheet.

This is general information, not tax advice. Individual situations change the columns, so run the numbers with a CPA before you commit; for wage tax and credit questions specific to your employer and your states, an enrolled agent or tax attorney is the right call.

Craig Lerch

Written by

Craig Lerch

Philadelphia broker with 37+ years and more than 4,000 transactions. He runs MoveUpPhilly to help relocating buyers land smarter.

Full bio

Now turn the reading into a plan.

Book a free relocation call and I will apply this to your timeline, budget, and shortlist.