The numbers a Philadelphia-to-New York mover should know: a Philly seller customarily writes about 2.3 percent of price in transfer tax at settlement, typical New York one-bedrooms rent for $3,000 to $5,200 a month, New York's state and city income taxes stack well above Pennsylvania's flat 3.07 percent, and the FARE Act means most New York tenants no longer pay a broker fee. The commute back is the one line that works in your favor: Amtrak covers the run in about 1 hour 10 to 1 hour 35 minutes, so the city you leave stays close for visits and for clients who keep a property behind. Every figure below was verified in October 2026.
I'm Craig Lerch, a broker at eXp Realty, and I help sellers exit Philadelphia cleanly on the way to their next chapter, including buyers headed to New York.
Selling your Philly home: the tax that lands on your side
Philadelphia's 4.578 percent transfer tax splits near evenly by custom, so the seller's side of the settlement sheet carries roughly 2.3 percent of price, in line with what buyers write in the same city (verified October 2026). On a $350,000 rowhome, that is roughly $8,000 out of the proceeds before your agent, attorney, and mortgage payoff. New York's transfer taxes are also customarily paid by the seller, 1.425 percent above $500,000 for the city plus 0.4 percent for the state, so the habit travels with you, but price the Philly line before you list.
The rent reality in New York
Typical one-bedroom rents run about $3,000 to $5,200 a month in 2026 depending on source and borough, with studios near $2,100, against the $1,350 to $1,850 Philadelphia one-bedrooms you are used to. Two rules changed the process in your favor: New York law caps the security deposit at one month's rent and requires return within 14 days of moving out (GOL 7-108), and the Fairness in Apartment Rental Expenses Act, in effect since June 11, 2025, makes the landlord's broker absorb the fee, so a tenant only pays if they hire their own agent (NYC Local Law 119 of 2024). The old 12-to-15-percent-of-annual-rent broker bill is gone for typical listings. Budget one month's rent as the deposit, ask for the landlord's written fee disclosure before you sign, and interview the co-op and condo rental boards the way you would a lender.
If you buy in New York instead
New York City's median sale price ran about $876,000 to $885,000 in 2026 against Philadelphia's roughly $279,000 to $295,000, so the three-to-one gap that made Philly affordable is the same gap you now face from the other side (Redfin; PropertyShark). Above $1 million, the buyer pays the state mansion tax starting at 1 percent with tiers rising to about 3.9 percent. Owner-occupied effective property rates run about 0.69 to 0.71 percent, and the co-op process adds board packages and interview layers that a Philadelphia fee-simple rowhome never had. A Philly rowhome is real estate you own outright with no board; a New York co-op is a share in a corporation the board has to approve, and the monthly maintenance replaces the property tax line.
The income tax stack you are about to gain
Pennsylvania's state tax is a flat 3.07 percent, and Philadelphia residents also paid the 3.735 percent wage tax on compensation (verified October 2026). In New York you trade both for the state's brackets, which top out near 10.9 percent, plus New York City's resident income tax of 3.078 to 3.876 percent (NYC Comptroller, verified October 2026). A typical mid-career salary sees its effective income tax rise by several points in the move, and New York does not have a wage-tax-style 1-percent suburban earned income tax to worry about, but it also has no offset for what you leave behind. The rule of thumb: the income tax bill goes up, the property tax bill goes down on a per-square-foot basis, and rent or the mortgage dwarfs both. Run your own numbers with a CPA before you commit to the timing of the sale.
What transit costs in New York
The MTA base subway and local bus fare is $3.00 as of January 4, 2026, single rides $3.50, with a $35 weekly fare cap and a 30-day unlimited pass around $132 to $138 (MTA, 2026). SEPTA's base fare is $2.90 with two free transfers, and the citywide TransPass runs about $96 to $116, so your monthly pass goes up modestly. The car math changes more: Philadelphia's residential permit runs $75 a year, while a New York garage can cost more per month than that permit costs per year, so most transplants who can, sell the second car with the house.
Keeping the Philadelphia connection
The reverse commute is the silver lining. Amtrak from 30th Street to New York Penn runs about 1 hour 10 to 1 hour 35 minutes; the budget route pairs SEPTA's Trenton Line with NJ Transit at $20.35 one way from Trenton, and buses run from about $8 to $40 (verified October 2026). Door to door, plan 2 to 2.5 hours each way, which makes Philadelphia a weekend-viable city to keep visiting, and the Main Line and river wards stay a listing away for the clients you leave behind.
The checklist for a Philadelphia-to-NYC move
- Price the seller's share of the 4.578 percent transfer tax into your net before you set the asking price.
- Coordinate the settlement date with the New York lease start; a 30-day gap in Philadelphia is cheaper than a month of bridge housing in Manhattan.
- Run the income tax comparison with a CPA: PA flat 3.07 percent versus NY state brackets plus the 3.078 to 3.876 percent city tax.
- Budget one month's rent as the security deposit and confirm no landlord-side broker fee under the FARE Act.
- Decide what happens to the car before you rent; New York parking can cost more per month than Philadelphia's $75 annual permit.
- Test the return trip at your actual hours before you commit to a twice-a-week rhythm.
Book a free call and we will price the sale of your Philadelphia home so the New York side starts on a clean settlement sheet.